Labor Day is meant to be a day to celebrate the working man–not “Working Man“, by Rush, which should be celebrated every day as a great prog rock anthem*. A day of rest to reflect on “the strength and esprit de corps of the trade and labor organizations” (as the wikipedia entry on Labor Day tells me). A noble concept, Labor Day.
But let’s be honest: Labor Day is about BBQ. End-of-summer picnics, coleslaw, and dinner on the deck one last time with family and friends before we have to get back to the grind of school and cooler weather. On Monday I honored this secondary meaning of the day by judging smoked and fried meat at the South Park Rib & Wing Challenge.
I’d love to give a play-by-play on each of the ribs and wings we sampled, but that’s impossible. By the time I’d finished sampling the first of the ten rib entries, my hands were a sticky mess (so I couldn’t use a pen) and my focus was squarely on evaluating the ribs in five categories: taste, texture, sauce, rub, and smokiness. No time for notes.
So what can I tell you? Well, the process itself was legit. We tasted “blind” so we didn’t know what came from who. (That was maybe the most poorly constructed sentence I’ve ever written.) We were secreted away in a dark corner of the clock building at the South Park Fairgrounds, away from the prying eyes of the public. There, the judges individually scored each rib on the aforementioned categories. After we’d sampled and scored all ten entries, the organizer tallied top scores and we re-tasted the top three to come to a consensus winner.
And the winner: Hogfather’s BBQ from down in (what old folks call) Little Washington. This makes me happy–their smokey goodness is but a short drive from Casa Burghertime.
Other top entries came from 2 Fat Guys (home to the longest lines at the festival and the best thing to come out of Massillon, OH since, well…they are the only good thing to come out Massillon, OH) and Hog Wild Bar-B-Que, who brought their big silver cylindrical smoker up from Ronceverte, WV.
What put these ribs at the top of the mountain of discarded bones? The first thing that hit me was how perfectly cooked they were. Fall-off-the-bone tender is cliché, and meat that’s falling off without any prodding can be mushy and unappealing. All three top entries pulled away with just the slightest tug, revealing a deep smoke ring, tender meat, and a thin layer of melting fat. Rubs were all unassuming, acting as flavor enhancers and crust creaters rather than playing first chair in the flavor orchestra that is a great rib. Sauces for all three of my favorites were pretty straight-forward Kansas City style, though Hog Wild’s had a touch of vinegar–maybe apple cider?–that gave it a nice tang.
Wings, with only two entries, was a quick tasting and judgement. Winner Mulligan’s presented a bright yellow, mustard-y wing flecked with what appeared to be diced black olives.
Judging isn’t for the faint of heart. I ate a lot of meat of varying quality in a short period of time. The experience, though, was fantastic and enlightening. So many variations on the theme of ribs and lots of ideas for how I can make mine better at home.
Many thanks to the organizers of the South Park Rib & Wing Challenge for the opportunity to throw my stomach into the ring to help judge. With this experience under my belt–or more accurately, spilling over my belt–I’m going to look into becoming a certified BBQ judge. That would be the crowning achievement in my education, vastly more important and relevant than either of my other higher ed credentials.
The festival appeared to be a resounding success and I imagine it’ll be back next year over Labor Day weekend. We had a very nice time there as a family on Saturday when we stopped by to check out the lay of the land before Monday’s judging. Kids activities and people watching on a beautiful late summer evening, with the added bonus that the promised clowns were nowhere to be seen, makes for a great end to the summer. Check it out next year…and be sure to get some ribs from Hogfather’s while you are there.
*Contrary to how it may seem with my frequent posts referencing Styx and Rush, I am not a prog rock fan. My freshman roomie Howard was. He arrived the first day of the semester with two boxes full of Dream Theater cassettes and cassingles of songs like “Silent Lucidity.” Mr. Wiener–yes, it was pronounced like that–also had the entire catalog of New Kids on the Block on tape which was puzzling on a number of levels. As a music major he should have known that NKOTB was just plain musical silliness (expected backlash from Mrs. B in 5…4…3…2…1). And as a devoutly Jewish person, his ownership of their Christmas album confused me greatly. Oh well…different strokes, I guess.
But that’s all beside the point, which is that I don’t want to be tagged a progressive rock fan. My apologies to any Supertramp fans who might be reading this.
Read Full Post »